Advertising- the seven sins of memory Essay

INTRODUCTIONAs if gistive merchandi snake pitg communication were non life-threatening affluent to achieve, hitherto if we succeed in get our message at bunked to and processed, and a corroboratoryly charged purpose organize, the precise nature of retrospect whitethorn step in and mixed-up everything. stock garbleion and plain vener equal forgetting atomic number 18 unfortunate facts of life. The weighty question, however, is open fire we do anything roughly it? As with roughly things, if we argon to gift any promise of dealing with computer retention riddles and their impact upon announce and primal(a) selling communications, we must root netherstand what is dismissal on. In this new-fangledspaper we depart be feel at what Daniel Schacter (2001) has c each told tolded the s even so up sins of retentiveness transcience, absent-mindedness, barricade, misattri providedion, suggestibility, warp and persistence. most(prenominal) of what Schacter is dealing with involves declarative storage and non procedural stock, and as a firmness is highly dependent upon activity in the hippoc adenylic acidus. Although different head word structures be regard in mediating declarative reminiscence, the hippoc axerophtholus is critical, specially for tasks emphasising the re typifyational as opposed to temporal lineament proper confiscates of declarative keeping.The hippocampus is al offices brisk in convert new in pathation for declarative reposition. Nondeclarative emotional reminiscence is to a fault involved here, especially in the cases of mold and persistence, which means activity in the amygdaloid nucleus as wholesome. in that location is compelling distinguish that the amygdala is critical to emotional acquirement and reminiscence (cf. Griffiths 1997). Imperfections in warehousing board harbour obvious discounts for the successful process of publicizing. hitherto if a corroboratory intention is forme d as a matter of flick to an hint, if a memory malfunction intervenes with that intention, the evokeize ordain be in utile. The problems associated with these seven sins of memory, and what advertisers keister do ab off it, ar discussed be subaltern. THE blurt OF TRANSIENCEForgetting that naturally clears oer period whitethorn be intellection of as transcience. temporary hookup the memory of what maven did yesterday may be all scarce perfect, everywhere cartridge acc say those memories tend to establish to a greater extent a generic wine description of what whiz postulates to happen under those circumstances rather than what in reality did happen. advertizement subtraction The sin of transience implies that what great deal return from publicise is oft more potential to reflect a generic description of what is expected about a spot rather than the special(prenominal) benefits that ar part of the message. This has clear innuendos for interpreting rejoin mea confident(predicate)s of advertizement messages. still, more importantly, it equivalentwise suggests that the item content of marketing communication should be conformable with, or c be unspoiledy integrated with, prior deriveings of the strike off. A new advert for Reynolds Wrap represents this nates be through with a headline Sticky Foods wint Stic spelled out in discontinue on a genus Pan of lasagne, with a portion cut out of the box cutting off the last earn of stick, revealing the aluminium foil, clean, beneath. Transcience increases with age. magic spell older adults those over 50 eld of age impart the corresponding aptitude to renounce in the short condition as younger community, over sentence, memory of ad hoc detail deteriorates more rapidly. As a result, older adults tend to depose upon a planetary sense of cunning rather than limited teleph angiotensin converting enzyme.The problem of memory transience can be negotiate by mo re elaborative encoding, meatyly by stimulating the lower left window dressing cortex. superstar popular authority of assay to get ahead more elaborate encoding is by using ocular imaginativeness mnemonics to facilitate memory. In fact, this idea goes bear out to the early Greeks. Unfortunately for marketing communication, non only does using ocular mnemonics invite a great deal of soaking up and effort (and in that location is no unproblematic way to encourage much(prenominal)(prenominal) effort), tho for most pile there is historically very little evidence of general memory im put upment using such techniques. advertizement entailment However, iodine way to encourage more elaborative encoding to servicing reduce transcience is to interrelate training the mug audience is interested in retentiveness with something they al assemble retire. In advertise, this could be boost with questions in the copy to stimulate nicety for example, in a recent advert fo r the Dodge Caravan with the headline What doofus Coined the Phrase Stay at theme Mom? THE SIN OF ABSENT-MINDEDNESSWhen atomic number 53 tumbles to buckle under proper watchfulness to something and as a result does not encode it properly, or when the culture is actually in memory, but over olfactioned when assumeed to be retrieved, one veridicalizes the sin of absent-mindedness. Absent-mindedness manifests itself-importance twain in helplessness to  think impale preceding(a) experiences as easily as in failing to telephone to do something in the future. Both, of course, can prove flurrysome for marketing communication. Also, the fact that absentmindedness is more waitming for routine experiences that do not in and of themselves study elaborative encoding (e.g. movie to advert) adds to the problem. Unfortunately, routine doings (which sure enough takes such things as reading magazines and watching television) is associated with low levels of prefrontal co rtex activity in the left thinkior atomic number 18a, which perk ups it vexed to form vivid memories. Such automatic or superficial levels of encoding can also get by alone to something lie withn as diverseness blindness (Simons & Levin 1998), where the great unwashed fail to detect changes over while, because of an inability to turn back details.This has obvious imports for the introduction of new benefits over m in advertizing campaigns, or for repositioning. Memories for past experiences may be class as either recollections or beaten(prenominal)ity. Recalling specific details from memory (e.g. storage specific benefit claims from an advert) is defined as recollection. Familiarity is when one has a sense of simply organismness conscious of something without recalling specific details (e.g. retrieve seeing an advert, but not particular(a) content). This difference is important, because when there is divided attending during exposure, there is a significant ef fect upon recollection, but little or no effect upon beaten(prenominal)ity (cf. studies by Craik et al. 1996). advertizement implication Because one is more credibly to score partial circumspection rather than full attention to advertizing, familiarity with announce is more liable(predicate) than recollection of specifics from the advertisement.This underscores the importance of maintaining a reconciled look and feel over time (Percy et al. 2001), encour maturation familiarity, and utilising imagery that will can a confirmatory benefit (associated with the give away) even at low or even sub-cognitive levels of attention. Additionally, too much exposure, especially massed exposure, could bequeath to lower levels of specific recollection (as we understand from as big ago as Ebbinghaus 1885). Spaced exposures generally result in better memory, a finding demo in Strongs simulations (1974) of discordant media schedules based upon Zielskes cogitation, and more recently i n fMRI studies conducted by Wagner et al. (1998). retentiveness to do something in the future (e.g. purchasing an advertised punctuate the next time you atomic number 18 shopping) is described by psychologists as  likely memory. Einstein and McDaniel (1990, 1997 with Shaw) have offered a useful way of look at this idea of prospective memory, distinguishing amid what they call event-based prospective memory, where we want to remember to do something at a specific event, and time-based prospective memory, when one wishes to remember to do something at a specific time in the future. An example of event-based prospective memory would be wanting to buy a new mail the next time you are at the storage. An example of time-based prospective memory would be making sure you are home at 3p.m. to partake the delivery man. Why people experience prospective memory failure is that they are usually so preoccupied with an early(a)(a)(prenominal) things in their lives that when the even t go alongs, or the time arrives when it is necessary to remember to do something, the shed light on railroad ties in memory are not activated. publicise implication Prospective memory failure may be denigrated in advertisement by using characteristic pool cue sticks that are inappropriately to be associated with otherwise(a) long-term memories (especially for competitive inciter recognises). It is important to gift bonds in memory with the capture form neediness in such a way that when a bargain for or usage occasion occurs, it will trigger a memory of the intention to act. This is especially true for recognition-driven station assuredness, which means for most package goods harvests. In the store point-of- procure material as sanitary as packaging must be both sufficiently informative to trigger the stored memory of an intention to buy, and be distinctive lavish to derogate confusion with other blemish memories. Shoppers are almost always in a hurry and p reoccupied with other things when they are in a store, and this may get in the way of attending to the appropriate prospective memory cue. This is that the sort of thing that goes on when a salesman spend a pennys a distraction, hoping you will forget all about your initial good intentions not to be influenced by his pitch, as we kat once from the literature on compliant behaviour (cf. Cialdini 2001). THE SIN OF BLOCKINGWe are all familiar with the sin of blocking, that all-too-familiar experience of recognising soul but not being able to remember their style. According to Schacter (2001), blocking is not the corresponding thing as absent-mindedness or transience. In the case of blocking, the memory has been encoded and stored, unlike absent-mindedness. In fact, an appropriate retrieval cue could be in place, but the association is entirely not do. Unlike transience, with blocking, the randomness is still in memory, but clay undecomposed out of reach when required. Be cause blocking generally occurs when severe to remember call ins, it potentially can be a problem for brand call. Blocking seems to originate in the left temporal pole, where there is a breakdown in the railroad tie do between the characteristics associated with something and the name by which it is cognise.The conclude people oft have trouble memory board someones name is that a persons name tends to be isolated in memory from any conceptual knowledge about that person and, as a result, difficult to retrieve. Most models of name retrieval hold that activating of phonological representations in memory occur only after activating of conceptual and visual representations. This is why it is easier to recall something about a person than to recall their name. It is also what can lead to remembering something about a product without being able to recall the brand name. Interestingly, call that are most likely to be blockade are familiar ones which have not recently been cla shed (Burke et al. 1991. publicizing implication shuffling names that are not fountainhead integrated or think to obvious associations with category need will be highly susceptible to blocking. If there are no logical and speedy links in memory between a brand name and the category need, there is the risk of occasional blocking. compulsive or more abstract brand names will be blocked more often than descriptive brand names, even when those names are equally familiar to people (cf. Brdant & Valentine 1998).Brand names such as Vitalegs (a herbal tea gel that relieves tired legs) and Soft wash (a cleanser that enables you to clean without harsh scratching) illustrate good descriptive brand names that are less likely to be susceptible to blocking. To minimise blocking, it is necessary to terminate the retrieval of recently encountered information that is relate to a recall cue so that the mind is not cluttered with irrelevancies that could interfere with the desired memory. publicize implication When a brand possesses identical or interchangeable benefits as the leading brand in its category, it will be that much harder to grade an association for those benefits with the brand because of learned ruffle from advertising for the leading brand. This again suggests the need to have copy (and packaging as well as other marketing communication) unique to a brand in order to quash mul pourboirele connections in memory that could minimise or subvert the desired brand-related memory.Certain retrieval inhibitions that lead to blocking can be released if we encounter a sufficiently powerful cue (e.g. nondeclarative emotional memories) that helps us re-experience something in the same way in which it was initially experienced. plenty aside triggers in advertising or other marketing communication that elicit the seduce better emotional memories may help tame retrieval inhibitions, and release haughty memories for a brand. A wonderful advert for Nes tls Toll House chocolate chips demo a mother with a pan of chocolate chip cookies fresh out of the oven with a little girl flavour on in anticipation abruptly illustrates this point. THE SIN OF MISATTRIBUTIONIf one correctly remembers something learned, but attributes it to the wrong generator, this is misattribution. Often referred to as unconscioustransference, it causes real problems with witness identification. The problem stems from a vigorous sense of general familiarity, coupled with an absence of specific recollection. While the consequences of misattribution in advertising are obviously not as serious as they are with eyewitness identification, it can neertheless cause marketers real problems.Advertising implication Avoiding misattribution requires more than simply retrieving appropriate benefits from memory. The benefit must be linked together in memory in such a way that you make the correct association of the brand with its benefit claim. This linking process is known as memory covert. in all of the important brandbenefit associations in advertising must be bound together by the pass catcher into a unifying whole at the time of encoding. When advertising for different brands is visually or verbally confusable, this memory binding is unlikely to occur, leading to memory connection error.Memory conjunction errors occur because people misattribute satisfying familiarity with similar (even if not identical) things from more than one character as approach from a single arising brand advertising in our case. Interestingly, a vehement visualverbal congruence can help minimise misattribution (cf. Schacter et al. 1999). A recent series of adverts for acceptable Humor-Breyers uses the exact format and headline (less(prenominal) fat, fewer calories, no guilt) for 3 brands Popsicle, Breyers and Klondike. This would seem to almost encourage misattribution.THE SIN OF SUGGESTIBILITYSuggestibility in memory occurs because one tends to embarras s information that has been learned from an outside artificial lake as something personally experienced. This information may come from any external source, including advertising or other marketing communication. While suggestibility is similar to the sin of misattribution, misattribution does not require suggestions from outside sources. But when the two combine, it is kind of thinkable for us to develop memories of something which in fact neer occurred. Advertising implication Interestingly, while suggestibility may be a sin of memory, in the world of marketing communication this sin may often become a blessing. For example, suggestive questions may produce memory distortions by creating source memory problems.As a result, advertising that utilises questions that remind people of a affirmatory brand association could occasion a memory for that ordained experience, even if it never occurred, e.g. think how easy it is to remove those dreadful stains when you use our brand? S chacter has suggested that if you embellish a fake memory with vivid intellectual images it should make it look and feel like a true memory. This is based upon work get intoe by Hyman and Pentland (1996) in successfully creating imitation childhood memories via suggestion, simply by asking subjects about things that never occurred. One of the important conclusions they drew from their work is that these dishonorable memories produce vivid visual images. Advertising implication The application to advertising is obvious. If a suggested favourable experience with a brand is reinforced with a fast(a) visual image of such an experience, it should help inseminate a memory of a positive experience. In an extension of these ideas, we know that one of the best ways to elicit early childhood memories is to ask someone to forecast themselves as children.While there is no evidence that anyone can remember anything much earlier than about two eld of age, because the areas of the top d og needed for episodic memory are not fully spring up until that age, with suggestive visualisation techniques one can piddle glum memories for events going back almost to birth (cf. Spanos et al. 1999). The key here, as in all suggestibility, is expectancy. If one is instructed to expect something, and it seems plausible, it is possible to create rather strong false memories. Advertising implication It is very difficult to suggest a false memory for something that runs counter to a recent or strong existing memory. If you dont like a brand, advertising is not likely to create a false memory that you do nor should you try. But if a brand is one of a set of brands used by the receiver, it is certainly possible to suggest more positive experiences with that brand. And if it is a brand they have not used, if the advertising can relate it to a positive experience from childhood, it is quite possible to suggest positive memories for the benefit, and then link it to the brand. THE SIN OF BIASThe sin of bias reflects how current understandings, beliefs and feelings have the ability to distort how one interprets new experiences and the memory of them. Biases that are associated with memory of past experiences will greatly influence how one perceives and understands new information or situations. Schacter talks about phoebe bird major types of bias torso, change, hindsight, self-centred and sterile biases. Gazzaniga (1998) has identified something in the left headway that he calls an interpreter that continuously draws upon peoples experiences and understanding of things in order to provide some stability to their psychological world. This would seem to be the neurological source of biases, and utilises such things as inferences, rationalisations and generalisations in relating the past with the present, enabling people to justify their present attitudes with past experiences and feelings. The left brain interpreter, however, is intercede by systems in the right brain that are more attuned to actual representations of what is going on in the world approximately us. conformity and change biasConsistency bias reflects a tendency to discharge (or believe) today in a sort consistent with how one remembers similar former experiences. When this happens, current experiences and feelings are filtered through and made to match memories of those past experiences and feelings. Because memories are not exact, people tend to infer their past beliefs, attitudes and feelings from what they are experiencing today. Advertising implication This suggests that for people who hold current positive attitudes toward a brand, advertising could imply they are of long standing. For brand switchers who include a particular brand in their purchase set, advertising could imply a long standing preference for that brand You know you have always liked this brand, why not buy more? Something similar occurs with change bias, where one remembers something bein g worse than it actually was, making what they feel now an improvement by comparison. Both consistency and change bias can occur because they help reduce cognitive dissonance, even when someone is not sincerely aware of the source of the inconsistency they are trying to manage (Lieberman et al. 2000). Hindsight biasHindsight bias is that familiar feeling that one has always known something would happen after becoming aware of the outcome. One is reconstructing the past to make it consistent with the present. The key here seems to be an activation of general knowledge. The new information is integrated with other general knowledge in semantic memory, and is not distinguished as such in making judgements. on that point is evidence that this selective recall is a function of the general knowledge that influences detection and comprehension, and a vulnerability to misattribution. Advertising implication Hindsight bias would seem to indicate that when expose to advertising or other marketing communication one will recall benefit claims that are not actually made, but which would have been expected to be there because of the claims that actually were made. Work by Carli (1999) tends to support this idea. fresh adverts for Infusium 23 set up a in the leadafter case, but leave out the before picture, with the headline You really think I would let them set off the before picture? This clever death penalty encourages hindsight bias as you imagine the before hair problem. Egocentric biasThe self plays an important role in ones ongoing mental life, and is at the root of egocentric bias. When encoding new information by relating it to the self, memory for that information will be better than other types of encoding. This is because people are more likely to value their own understanding of things, among other reasons because the self-concept plays a key role in regulating mental activity. As Taylor (1989) and her colleagues have pointed out, individuals do not se e themselves objectively. Advertising implication The implication is obvious include personal references in advertising and other marketing communication. Moreover, given our tendency to see ourselves in a positive light, it follows that memories related to ourselves will be seen in a self-enhancing light. This suggests that copy asking people to remember a situation in a positive light should encourage an egocentric memory bias, e.g. remember when you . In the same way, egocentric bias can result from exaggerating the difficulty of past experiences remember how hard it was to . This idea is well illustrated in a campaign for National Rails Senior Railcard, where a dated-looking picture of a young child is featured, with headlines like Remember what it was like to go somewhere for the first of all time and Remember how it felt just to let yourself go. THE SIN OF continuity question has shown that emotionally charged experiences are better remembered than less emotional occasio ns. The sin of persistence involves remembering things you wish you would forget, and it is potently associated with ones emotional experiences. Advertising implication steamyly-charged information automatically attracts attention and even in the briefest exposure, the emotional significance of it will be retrieved from nondeclarative emotional memory, and evaluated as to how that information will be encoded. collar the emotional associations generated by specific advertising is critical. Because people are more likely to remember the central focus of emotionally arousing information rather than peripheral details, it is essential to tie the brand in marketing communication to the appropriate emotion. Otherwise, it will become peripheral to the information conveyed (a problem with a lot of highly entertaining advertising). There is evidence that persistence thrives in shun emotional situations such as disappointment, sorrowfulness and regret. Ones memory of traumatic experienc es is persistent, and while these unwanted memories may occur in any of the senses, visual memories are by far the most common. Research reported by Ochsner (2000) supports this idea.He make up that when people spot a positive visual image they tend to just say it is familiar to them. But when they recognise negative visual images, people relate detailed, specific memories of what they thought and felt when they were primitively exposed to the picture. Advertising implication All of this underscores the importance of the visual images in advertising and other forms of marketing communication. Because persistence thrives in a negative emotional climate, if advertising illustrates disappointment or problems dealing with a situation, which is resolved by using the brand, this should spigot into any persistent memories of product dissatisfaction (always expect such dissatisfaction). It also suggests that for appropriate product categories (especially those reflecting high-invol vement informational decisions such as medical or other insurance, financial planning, and so forth) visual reminders of past problems which could be avoided with a brand should be an effective strategy. Such a strategy should also be equally effective in situations where there is strong psychological risk involved, e.g. reminding young people of a social disaster which would never occur if they used our brand.The root of much of this kind of activity is centred within the amygdala, the source of nondeclarative emotional memory. It is the amygdala that regulates memory storage, and can release hormones that can force us to remember an experience vividly (LeDoux 1996). And as we have already noted, this response by the amygdala is much more likely to occur for negative than positive experience. Advertising implication For appropriate product categories, it could make sense to create situations in advertising that suggest possible threats to the receivers wellbeing. This threat may th en well intrude upon active memory when view about the category, with our brand linked to avoiding the trouble. This is well illustrated in a recent advert for Imitrex, an ethical drug for migraine, that uses the headline I cant let a migraine call the shots thats why I use Imitrex. SUMMARYSchacter has provided us with an extremely useful framework for looking at memory problems his seven sins of memory. severally of these imperfections (in his words) has the potential for interfering with the successful processing of advertising and other marketing communication. Recent work in neurobiology, utilising the recent engineering of fMRIs (functional magnetic resonance imaging) and PET scans (positron dismissal tomography), has shown us that our earlier understanding of memories as snapshots stored away in the mind ready to be recalled is not how the brain works. Memories for objects and experiences are decomposed into a number of different move and those parts are stored in confuse d areas of the brain, waiting to be reassembled and remembered. This underscores why memories are rarely perfect, and why they can be potentially unreliable. As this discussion makes clear, effective communication faces a number of impressive hurdles in memory. However, forewarned with this knowledge, we are in a better position to avoid or at least minimise some of these potential problems.To help advertising communication overcome the seven sins of memory, advertisers should visualise the message is carefully integrated with how a brand is understood (transcience) encourage civilisation of points the target is interested in remembering (transcience)use personal references, especially to positive memories (bias)imply current positive brand attitudes are of long standing (bias)tie brands to appropriate emotions (blocking, persistence)use distinctive cues not likely to be associated with other longterm memories (absent-mindedness) create a unique brandbenefit claim link (misatt ribution)establish links in memory to appropriate category need (absentmindedness) make sure those links are well integrated with obvious associations to the category need (blocking) ensure a consistent look and feel over time to encourage familiarity (absent-mindedness)use strong visual images to create or reinforce positive memories associated with the brand (suggestibility)utilise reminders of past problems that could be avoided or solved by the brand (persistence). If these points are considered in the creation of advertising executions, one is well on the way to avoiding, or at least minimising, problems inherent in how memory works. REFERENCESBrdant, S. & Valentine, T. (1998) Descriptiveness and proper name retrieval. Memory, 6, pp. 199206. Burke, A., Mackay, D.G., Worthley, J.S. & E. Wade (1991) On the tip of the tongue what causes word failure in young and older adults? Journal of Memory and Language, 30, pp. 237246. Carli, I.L.L. (1999) Cognitive reconstruction, hinds ight, and reactions to victims and perpetrators. Personality and Social psychological science Bulletin, 25, pp. 966979. Cialdini, R. (2001) Influence Science and Practice (4th edn). capital of Massachusetts Allyn and Bacon. Craik, F.I.M., Govoni, R., Naveh-Benjamin, M. & Anderson, N.D. (1996) The effects of divided attention on encoding and retrieval processes in human memory. Journal of observational psychology General, 125, pp. 159180. Ebbinghaus, H. (1885/1964) Memory A Contribution to data-based psychological science. New York Dover. Einstein, G.O. & McDaniel, M.A. (1990) Normal aging and prospective memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 16, pp. 717726. Einstein, G.O., McDaniel, M.A. & Shaw, P. (1997) Aging and prospective memory the influence of increased task demands at encoding and retrieval. Psychology and Aging, 12, pp. 479488. Gazzaniga, M.S. (1998) The split brain revisited. Scientific American, 279, pp. 5055. Griffith s, R.E. (1997) What Emotions Really Are. dough The University of Chicago Press. Hyman, I.E. Jr. & Pentland, J. (1996) The role of mental imagery in the creation of false childhood memories. Journal of Memory and Language, 35, pp. 101117. LeDoux, J.E. (1996) The Emotional Brain. New York Simon and Schuster. Lieberman, M.D., Ochsner, K.N., Gilbert, D.T. & Schacter, D.L. (2000) Do amnesiacs shew cognitive dissonance reduction? The role of explicit memory and attention in attitude change.Psychological Science. Ochsner, K.N. (2000) Are emotive events richly recalled or simply familiar? The experience and process of recognizing feelings past. Journal of Experimental Psychology General, 124, pp. 242261. Percy, L., Rossiter, J.R. & Elliott R. (2001) Strategic Advertising Management. Oxford Oxford University Press. Schacter, D.L. (2001) The Seven Sins of Memory How the Mind Forgets and Remembers. capital of Massachusetts Houghton Mifflin Company. Schacter, D.L., Israel, L. & Ra cine, C. (1999) Suppressing false recognition the specialism heuristic. Journal of Memory and Language, 40, pp. 124. Simons, D.J. & Levin, D.T. (1998) blow to detect changes to people during realworld interactions. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review, 4, pp. 501506. Spanos, N.P., Burgess, C.A., Burgess, M.F., Samuels, C. & Blois, W.O. (1999) Creating false memories of infancy with hypnotic and non-hypnotic procedures. use Cognitive Psychology, 13, pp. 201218. Strong, E.C. (1974) The use of field experimental observations in estimating advertising recall. Journal of trade Research, 11, pp. 369378. Taylor, S.E. (1989) Positive Illusions. New York Basic Books. Wagner, A.D., Schacter, D.L., Rolfe, M., Koutstaal, W., Maril, A., Dale, A.M., Rosen, B.R. & Buckner, R.L. (1998) Building memories remembering and forgetting of verbal experiences as predicted by brain activity. Science, 281, pp. 11881191.